In search of the best methods for multivariate selection analysis
Abstract
Regression is an important method for characterizing the form of natural selection from individual-based data. Many kinds of regression analysis exist, but few are regularly employed in studies of natural selection. I provide an overview of some of the main underused types of regression analysis by applying them to test analyses of viability selection for lamb traits in Soay sheep (Ovis aries). This exercise highlights known problems with existing methods, uncovers some new ones and also reveals ways to harness underused methods to get around these problems. I first estimate selection gradients using generalized linear models, combined with recently published methods for obtaining quantitatively interpretable selection gradient estimates from arbitrary regression models of trait-fitness relationships. I then also apply generalized ridge regression, the lasso and projection-pursuit regression, in each case also deriving selection gradients. I compare inferences of nonlinear selection by diagonalization of the matrix and by projection-pursuit regression. Selection gradient estimates generally correspond across different regression methods. Although there is little evidence for nonlinear selection in the test data sets, very problematic aspects of the behaviour of analysis based on diagonalization of the are apparent. In addition to better-known problems, (i) the direction and magnitude of estimated major axes of quadratic selection are biased towards directions of phenotype that have little variance, and (ii) the magnitudes of selection of major axes of variance-standardized are not themselves interpretable in any standardized way. While all regression-based methods for analysis of selection have useful properties, projection-pursuit regression seems to stand out. This method can (i) provide both dimensionality reduction, (ii) be the basis for inference of quantitatively interpretable selection gradients and (iii) by characterizing major axes of selection, rather than of linear or quadratic selection separately, provide biologically interpretable inference of nonlinear selection.
Citation
Morrissey , M B 2014 , ' In search of the best methods for multivariate selection analysis ' , Methods in Ecology and Evolution , vol. 5 , no. 10 , pp. 1095-1109 . https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210X.12259
Publication
Methods in Ecology and Evolution
Status
Peer reviewed
ISSN
2041-210XType
Journal article
Description
The collection of the Soay sheep data is supported by the National Trust for Scotland and QinetQ, with funding from NERC, the Royal Society and the Leverhulme Trust.Collections
Items in the St Andrews Research Repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Integrating the theories of kin selection and sexual selection
Faria, G. S. (University of St Andrews, 2019-12-03) - Thesis -
Changes in selective pressures associated with human population expansion may explain metabolic and immune related pathways enriched for signatures of positive selection
Vatsiou, Alexandra; Bazin, Eric; Gaggiotti, Oscar Eduardo (2016-07-21) - Journal articleBackground: The study of local adaptation processes is a very important research topic in the field of population genomics. There is a particular interest in the study of human populations because they underwent a process ... -
Selection on the fly : short-term adaptation to an altered sexual selection regime in Drosophila pseudoobscura
Barata, Carolina; Snook, Rhonda R; Ritchie, Michael G; Kosiol, Carolin (2023-07-04) - Journal articleExperimental evolution studies are powerful approaches to examine the evolutionary history of lab populations. Such studies have shed light on how selection changes phenotypes and genotypes. Most of these studies have not ...