A case study of a land reform project in KwaZulu-Natal with reference to the Nkaseni Restitution Land Claim.
Loading...
Date
2010
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
The primary aim of this research was to examine the processes involved in the implementation
of land reform policies in South Africa with specific reference to the Nkaseni Land Restitution
Claim in the Midlands of KwaZulu-Natal. The objective was to conduct an in-depth diagnostic
study with a view to understanding the nature of the challenges, and to propose interventions
that could improve land reform processes and the functioning of communal projects in the
country.
The hypothesis of this research was that the South African government's attempts at land reform
have thus far failed to live up to expectations. Part of this research aimed to investigate this
hypothesis using the Nkaseni Communal Project as a case study. A number of issues were
identified as findings in this research and this report aims to present these issues. Through
this study, the pillars of the land reform programme in South Africa were discussed as tenure
reform, restitution and redistribution. While mention of the other land reform programmes was
made, emphasis was placed mainly on the restitution policy which is the focus of this research.
In this research, the experience of land reform in Less-Developed Countries such as Brazil,
Kenya, Tanzania and China, has been reviewed. A lesson learnt from developing countries is
that tensions and potential conflicts can hinder the process of land reform. It was also established
that land reform is time-consuming, expensive and difficult.
Some of the issues identified fall outside the mandate of the Department of Land Affairs, which
recommends a clear framework for effective role-player participation with other government
departments and other relevant stakeholders. A clear policy is needed on post-transfer support for
land reform communal projects. This includes clarifying the specific roles, functions and powers
of the different stakeholders.
This study was also able to provide some evidence that there are numerous challenges that
are being experienced by communal-managed projects that have been set up within the KZN
Province. A number of the challenges emanate from poorly-drafted Constitutions of the
Communal Property Institution as well as poor implementation of projects. The study was
able to illustrate that land title can be transferred to the Communal Property Institutions, but that
does not translate into the realization of secure individual rights of members of the institution. It
was also noted that failure to address issues relating to individual rights allocation can be one of
the major sources of conflict within Communal Projects. The research findings revealed that there
was very little focus on empowering beneficiaries of communal projects to manage their newlyacquired
resources once transfer of land had taken place.
Also noted is that there was a lack of understanding of the Trust (as an institution) by some of
the Trust members. Lack of co-operative governance was raised as a key issue hindering support
from other stakeholders. The study revealed that there was a lack of systems or processes of
dealing with multiple interests of Trust members. There was poor representation of women
within decision-making structures.
Lack of skills transfer to land reform beneficiaries is another contributing factor to the many
challenges that are faced by the Communal Property Institutions. Beneficiary training and
capacity building are key recommendations in the findings. From the start of the land reform
programme, it was recognized that, given South Africa’s Agricultural history, transferring
skills to beneficiaries was to be one of the key challenges and determinants of the land reform
programme’s success. In the light of this study, a more integrated method of skills transfer at
the community level would have many advantages, as it would help alleviate a number of the
challenges currently experienced by the land reform projects.
Lastly, the study also indicated that land reform beneficiaries were rarely experienced in making
independent decisions. It is clear from this research that there is no blueprint approach to land
reform, as each project should be designed for the particular conditions to be effective. The
important aspects of both individual and communal tenure should be properly understood when
reform initiative attempts to change social relations in rural areas are undertaken. There must be
flexibility in policies regarding farm size, while support must also be given to proper training and
extension aimed at increasing the individual farmer's managerial ability.
Description
Thesis (MPA)-University of KwaZulu-Natal, Westville, 2010.
Keywords
Land reform--KwaZulu-Natal--Nkaseni., Land tenure--KwaZulu-Natal--Nkaseni., Land settlement--KwaZulu-Natal--Nkaseni., Theses--Public administration.