A representação do ato de ensinar: continuidades e rupturas da concepção de ensino na pedagogia tradicional, na psicologia histórico-cultural e na pedagogia histórico-crítica : uma análise a partir das teses e dissertações no Portal da CAPES
Carregando...
Data
2011-02-21
Autores
Baldan, Merilin [UNESP]
Título da Revista
ISSN da Revista
Título de Volume
Editor
Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp)
Resumo
Ao estudar a história da educação e a história das ideias pedagógicas observamos no século XX o embate entre o tradicional e o inovador. A crítica promulgada pela Escola Nova contra o Ensino Tradicional denota aspecto negativo do ato de ensinar e, invariavelmente, as ideias pedagógicas que defendem o ato de ensinar são aproximadas com o termo “tradicional”. As correntes pedagógicas que defendem o ato de ensinar, dentre elas: a Pedagogia Tradicional (PT), a Psicologia Histórico-Cultural (PsHC) e a Pedagogia Histórico-Crítica (PsHC); tem sido alvo de comparações e de críticas pelos movimentos contemporâneos que fazem a crítica ao ensino, denominando-as, sob o julgo negativo do termo “tradicional”. Assim algumas questões têm nos inquietado: Seria possível que a aproximação entre a PT, a PsHC e a PeHC? Em que medida há aproximações e rupturas nas ideias pedagógicas? Quais os interesses em aproximá-las ou em distanciá-las? O objetivo geral foi de analisar a defesa do ato de ensinar da PT, da PsHC e da PeHC presente na história das ideias pedagógicas. Para tal, utilizamos como categorias de análise a concepção de sociedade, concepção de homem, concepção de educação, concepção do ato de ensinar (processo de ensino aprendizagem), concepção de professor e concepção de aluno. Os objetivos específicos foram (a) investigar a representação do ato de ensinar das correntes pedagógicas nas teses e dissertações presentes no portal da CAPES e (b) analisar a relação entre o “tradicional” e o “moderno” na construção histórica das ideias pedagógicas. O referencial teóricometodológico ancora-se na história das ideias pedagógicas, articulando o materialismo histórico-dialético e as contribuições da Escola dos Annales. A revisão bibliográfica compreendeu o levantamento e a análise de vinte e uma produções acadêmicocientíficas...
By studying the history of education and the history of pedagogical ideas in the twentieth century we see the clash between traditional and innovative. The criticism against promulgated by the New School and Traditional Shool denotes negative aspect of the act of teaching and, invariably, the pedagogical ideas that defend the act of teaching is approached with the term traditional. The pedagogical trends that advocate the act of teaching, including: Traditional Pedagogy (PT), the Historical-Cultural Psychology (PsHC) and Historical-Critical Pedagogy (PsHC) has been the subject of comparisons and criticisms by the contemporary movements that make the critique of education, calling them, under the yoke of the negative term traditional. So we have some unsettled issues: Is it possible that the rapprochement between the PT, and PsHC PeHC? To what extent there are breaks in approaches and pedagogical ideas? What interests or bring them to alienate them? The overall objective was to analyze the act of defending the teaching of PT, and PsHC PeHC present in the history of pedagogical ideas. To this end, we use as categories of analysis the conception of society, concept of man, concept of education, concept of the act of teaching (teaching-learning process), concept of teacher and student concept. The specific objectives were (a) to investigate the representation of the act of teaching pedagogical trends in theses and dissertations present the portal of CAPES and (b) examine the relationship between the traditional and modern in the historical construction of pedagogical ideas. The theoretical and methodological framework is anchored in the history of pedagogical ideas, articulating the historical and dialectical materialism and the contributions of the Annales School. The literature review included the survey and analysis of twenty-one academicscientific productions, eight and thirteen... (Complete abstract click electronic access below)
By studying the history of education and the history of pedagogical ideas in the twentieth century we see the clash between traditional and innovative. The criticism against promulgated by the New School and Traditional Shool denotes negative aspect of the act of teaching and, invariably, the pedagogical ideas that defend the act of teaching is approached with the term traditional. The pedagogical trends that advocate the act of teaching, including: Traditional Pedagogy (PT), the Historical-Cultural Psychology (PsHC) and Historical-Critical Pedagogy (PsHC) has been the subject of comparisons and criticisms by the contemporary movements that make the critique of education, calling them, under the yoke of the negative term traditional. So we have some unsettled issues: Is it possible that the rapprochement between the PT, and PsHC PeHC? To what extent there are breaks in approaches and pedagogical ideas? What interests or bring them to alienate them? The overall objective was to analyze the act of defending the teaching of PT, and PsHC PeHC present in the history of pedagogical ideas. To this end, we use as categories of analysis the conception of society, concept of man, concept of education, concept of the act of teaching (teaching-learning process), concept of teacher and student concept. The specific objectives were (a) to investigate the representation of the act of teaching pedagogical trends in theses and dissertations present the portal of CAPES and (b) examine the relationship between the traditional and modern in the historical construction of pedagogical ideas. The theoretical and methodological framework is anchored in the history of pedagogical ideas, articulating the historical and dialectical materialism and the contributions of the Annales School. The literature review included the survey and analysis of twenty-one academicscientific productions, eight and thirteen... (Complete abstract click electronic access below)
Descrição
Palavras-chave
Educação, Educação - Historia, Pedagogia critica, Pedagogia tradicional, Pedagogia histórico-crítica, Psicologia historico-cultural, Correntes pedagógicas, História das idéias pedagógicas, Traditional pedagogy, Pedagogy historical and critical, Historical-cultural psychology, Current teaching, Teaching ideas history, History of education
Como citar
BALDAN, Merilin. A representação do ato de ensinar: continuidades e rupturas da concepção de ensino na pedagogia tradicional, na psicologia histórico-cultural e na pedagogia histórico-crítica : uma análise a partir das teses e dissertações no Portal da CAPES. 2011. 237 f. Dissertação (mestrado) - Universidade Estadual Paulista, Faculdade de Ciências e Letras de Araraquara, 2011.