Goidts, Esther
[UCL]
van Wesemael, Bas
[UCL]
Crucifix, Michel
[UCL]
Uncertainties in soil organic carbon (SOC) stock assessments are rarely quantified even though they are critical in determining the significance of the results. Previous studies on this topic generally focused on a single variable involved in the SOC stock calculation (SOC concentration, sampling depth, bulk density and rock fragment content) or on a single scale, rather than using an integrated approach (i.e. taking into account interactions between variables). This study aims to apply such an approach to identify and quantify the uncertainties in SOC stock assessments for different scales and spatial landscape units (LSU) under agriculture. The error propagation method (delta method) was used to quantify the relative contribution of each variable and interaction involved to the final SOC stock variability. Monte Carlo simulations were used to cross-check the results. Both methods converged (r2=0.78). As expected, the coefficient of variation of the SOC stock increased across scales (from 5 to 35%), and was higher for grassland than for cropland. Although the main source of uncertainty in the SOC stock varied according to the scale and the LSU considered, the variability of SOC concentration (due to errors from the laboratory and to the high SOC spatial variability) and of the rock fragment content were predominant. When assessing SOC stock at the landscape scale, one should focus on the precision of SOC analyses from the laboratory, the reduction of SOC spatial variability (using bulk samples, accurate re-sampling, high sampling density or stratified sampling), and the use of equivalent masses for SOC stock comparison. The regional SOC stock monitoring of agricultural soils in southern Belgium allows the detection of an average SOC stock change of 20% within 11 years if very high rates of SOC stock changes occur (1 t C ha-1 year-1).
- Bock, etablissement et cartographie des teneurs bruits de fond en elements traces metalliques et micropolluants organiques dans les sols de la Region wallonne (2003)
- Boucneau, Pédologie - Themata, 5, 67 (1998)
- Bowman, Communications in Soil Science & Plant Analysis, 33, 1629 (2002)
- Brye, Communications in Soil Science & Plant Analysis, 34, 1637 (2003)
- Conant, Journal of Environmental Quality, 32, 278 (2003)
- De Leenheer, Pédologie, 18, 208 (1968)
- De Vos, Soil Science Society of America Journal, 69, 500 (2005)
- DEFRA (Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs) 2003. Sampling strategies and soil monitoring. Final Report on Project SP 0514, DEFRA, London.
- Delcourt, Computers & Electronics in Agriculture, 14, 179 (1996)
- Díaz-Zorita, Communications in Soil Science & Plant Analysis, 30, 739 (1999)
- Dileep, Soil Science Society of America Journal, 72, 1708 (2008)
- Don, Geoderma, 141, 272 (2007)
- EC, Proposal for a Directive of the european parliament and of the council establishing a framework for the protection of soil and amending Directive 2004/35/EC (2006)
- Ellert, Soil Science Society of America Journal, 66, 1687 (2002)
- Falloon, Soil Use & Management, 19, 265 (2003)
- Falloon, Soil Use & Management, 22, 274 (2006)
- Freibauer, Geoderma, 122, 1 (2004)
- Garten, Journal of Environmental Quality, 28, 1359 (1999)
- Geypens, Precision Agriculture, 1, 319 (2000)
- Goidts, Geoderma, 141, 341 (2007)
- Goodman, Journal of The American Statistical Association, 55, 708 (1960)
- Goovaerts, European Journal of Soil Science, 45, 79 (1994)
- Hammersley, J.M. & Handscomb, D.C . 1964. Monte Carlo Methods. Methuen London.
- Hanotiaux, Updated legend of Belgium soils map. Technical report (1992)
- Heuvelink, Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems, 50, 255 (1998)
- Janik, L. , Spouncer, L. , Correll, R. & Skjemstad, J . 2002. Sensivity analysis of the RothC soil carbon model (Ver. 26.3 Excel)., National Carbon Accounting - Technical report no.30, Australian Greenhouse Office, Canberra, ACT, Australia
- Johnson, Soil Science, 150, 637 (1990)
- Jolivet, Communications in Soil Science & Plant Analysis, 29, 2227 (1998)
- Jones, Stochastic Hydrology & Hydraulics, 3, 179 (1989)
- Kern, Soil Science Society of America Journal, 58, 439 (1994)
- Ku, Engineering & Instrumentation, 70C, 263 (1966)
- Kucharik, Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 58, 58 (2003)
- Lark, European Journal of Soil Science, 55, 611 (2004)
- Lark, European Journal of Soil Science, 56, 307 (2005)
- Lettens, European Journal of Soil Science, 58, 1244 (2007)
- Lindberg, Manual on Uncertainties, Graphing, and the Vernier Caliper. Institute of Technology, Rochester (2000)
- Lowther, Communications in Soil Science & Plant Analysis, 21, 457 (1990)
- Mardia, K.V. , Kent, J.T. & Bibby, J.M . 1979. Multivariate Analysis. p. 521. Academic Press, London.
- Meersmans, Geoderma, 143, 1 (2008)
- Miller, Erosion and Productivity of Soils Containing Rock Fragments (1984)
- Milne, Journal of Environmental Management, 49, 413 (1997)
- Milne, Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 122, 3 (2007)
- Morton, New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research, 43, 367 (2000)
- Morvan, Science of the Total Environment, 391, 1 (2008)
- Muleta, Journal of Hydrology, 306, 127 (2005)
- Ogle, Global Change Biology, 9, 1521 (2003)
- Ogle, Global Change Biology, 12, 516 (2006)
- Post, Environmental Modelling & Software, 23, 125 (2008)
- Poussart, Environmental Management, 33, S416 (2004)
- Rice, Mathematical Statistics and Data Analysis - Second Edition, 149 (1995)
- Robertson, Oecologia, 96, 451 (1993)
- Rubinstein, Simulation and the Monte Carlo Method (1981)
- Saby, Global Change Biology, 14, 2432 (2008)
- Schwager, Soil Science, 167, 194 (2002)
- Sleutel, Soil Use & Management, 22, 342 (2006)
- Sleutel, Global Change Biology, 9, 1193 (2003)
- Smith, Global Change Biology, 10, 1878 (2004)
- Soil Survey Staff, Soil Survey Manual - U.S. Dept. Agriculture Handbook No. 18 (1951)
- Sokal, Freeman W.H. & Company, New York (1995)
- Soon, Communications in Soil Science & Plant Analysis, 22, 943 (1991)
- Sutherland, Hydrobiologia, 389, 153 (1998)
- VandenBygaart, Global Change Biology, 10, 983 (2004)
- Walkley, Soil Science, 37, 29 (1934)
- Wang, Australian Journal of Soil Science, 34, 545 (1996)
- Weisstein, E.W . (1999). Error Propagation - From MathWorld - A Wolfram Web Resource [WWW document]. URL http://mathworld.wolfram.com/ErrorPropagation.html [accessed December 2007]
- Wells, The method of least squares - Lecture notes 18 (1971)
- Wilding, Assessment Methods for Soil Carbon, 69 (2000)
- Yadav, Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 123, 280 (2008)
- Zar, Biostatistical Analysis - Fourth Edition (1999)
- Zhang, Geoderma, 119, 261 (2004)
- Zirlewagen, Forest Ecology & Management, 248, 43 (2007)
- Lide (1981)
Bibliographic reference |
Goidts, Esther ; van Wesemael, Bas ; Crucifix, Michel. Magnitude and sources of uncertainties in soil organic carbon (SOC) stock assessments at various scales. In: European Journal of Soil Science, Vol. 60, no. 5, p. 723-739 (2009) |
Permanent URL |
http://hdl.handle.net/2078.1/35321 |