DiscussionGargantuavis is an insular basal ornithurine: a comment on Mayr et al., 2020, ‘A well-preserved pelvis from the Maastrichtian of Romania suggests that the enigmatic Gargantuavis is neither an ornithurine bird nor an insular endemic’
Introduction
Mayr et al. (2020) describe an interesting pelvis from the Maastrichtian of the Haţeg basin in Romania, which they consider as closely resembling that of Gargantuavis philoinos Buffetaut and Le Loeuff, 1998, from the Late Cretaceous of France and Spain. We agree with this identification, which does indicate that the Gargantuaviidae (as defined by Buffetaut and Angst, 2019) were not restricted to the Ibero-Armorican island, as previously suggested (Buffetaut & Angst, 2016a; Angst & Buffetaut, 2017), but were also present on the Haţeg island of the Late Cretaceous European archipelago. However, we disagree with several of the assertions, interpretations and conclusions of Mayr et al., especially concerning the systematic position and palaeobiogeographical history of Gargantuaviidae, as detailed below.
Institutional abbreviations: MC: Musée de Cruzy; MDE: Musée des Dinosaures, Espéraza; NHMUK: Natural History Museum, London.
Section snippets
Association of other skeletal elements with Gargantuavis pelves
Mayr et al. note that the femora and cervical vertebra that have been referred to Gargantuavis philoinos (Buffetaut and Le Loeuff, 1998, Chinsamy et al., 2014; Buffetaut & Angst, 2013; Angst and Buffetaut, 2017, Buffetaut and Angst, 2019) ‘cannot be assigned to G. philoinos with certainty, since these bones were not found in direct association with pelvic elements’ and therefore limit their discussion of the systematic position of Gargantuavis to the various pelvic elements described from
Lines of arrested growth
In their histological study of the femur from Villespassans, Chinsamy et al. (2014) reported the presence of lines of arrested growth. Apparently implying that these LAGs can be of phylogenetic significance, Mayr et al. comment that lines of arrested growth ‘among crown group birds are only found in the Apterygidae (kiwis) and Dinornithidae (moas), but [...] are present in phylogenetically more basal birds and non-avian dinosaurs’. This is erroneous: LAGs are present in many groups of
Breadth of pelvis
Commenting on the great breadth of the pelvis in Gargantuavis, Mayr et al. state that ‘the pelves of terrestrial flightless neornithine birds, by contrast, are much more elongated and narrower than the pelvis of Gargantuavis’ - a comment already made by Mayr (2009) in connection with his erroneous suggestion that Gargantuavis may have been a pterosaur. As already noted by Buffetaut and Le Loeuff (2010), the pelves of terrestrial flightless neornithines are not necessarily narrow. Among extinct
Systematic position
We (Buffetaut and Angst, 2016a, Buffetaut and Angst, 2019; Angst & Buffetaut, 2017) consider Gargantuavis philoinos as a basal ornithurine, on the basis of the number of synsacral vertebrae (probably 10), the highly heterocoelous character of the cervical vertebrae and the advanced condition of the distal end of the femur. This conclusion is not shared by Mayr et al., who, as noted above, restrict their analysis to the pelvis and conclude that Gargantuavis is not an ornithurine but a
Palaeobiogeographical interpretation
Mayr et al. claim that, contrary to previous interpretations (Buffetaut & Le Loeuff, 1998; Buffetaut & Angst, 2016a; Angst & Buffetaut, 2017), Gargantuavis cannot be considered as the result of insular evolution. In fact, the discovery of a Gargantuavis-like fossil on the Haţeg island only shows that gargantuaviids were not restricted to the Ibero-Armorican island, as previously envisioned on the basis of a fossil record that was restricted to France and Spain. As both the Haţeg area and the
Conclusion
While the discovery of a Gargantuavis-like pelvis in the Maastrichtian of Romania does invalidate the hypothesis that this giant bird was endemic to the Ibero-Armorican island, as correctly noted by Mayr et al., the interpretation of the systematic position and biogeographical history of gargantuaviids put forward by these authors is based on various erroneous or flawed assumptions and must be rejected. We consider that gargantuaviids were large, flightless basal ornithurines, at an
Acknowledgments
Thanks to Sandra Chapman for access to hesperornithiform specimens in the Natural History Museum, London. We thank the editor of Cretaceous Research, Dr Eduardo Koutsoukos, and an anonymous reviewer for their comments.
References (46)
On some bird remains from the Upper Cretaceous of Transsylvania
Geological Magazine
(1913)- et al.
Paleobiology of Giant Flightless Birds
(2017) - et al.
First record of the Late Cretaceous giant bird Gargantuavis philoinos from the Iberian Peninsula
Annales de Paléontologie
(2017) - et al.
‘‘Terror Birds’’ (Phorusrhacidae) from the Eocene of Europe imply Trans-Tethys dispersal
PloS One
(2013) - et al.
Bone histology sheds new light on the ecology of the dodo (Raphus cucullatus, Avec, Columbiformes)
Scientific Reports
(2017) - et al.
Gross and biometric studies on pelvic bone of the Emu (Dromaius novaehollandiae)
Indian Journal of Veterinary Science and Biotechology
(2019) - et al.
Dinosaurs and the island rule: The dwarfed dinosaursfrom Haţeg Island
Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology
(2010) Kreuzbein, Becken und Plexus lumbosacralis der Vögel
Mémoires de l’Académie Royale des Sciences et des Lettres de Danemark, Section des Sciences
(1933)- et al.
New evidence of a giant bird from the Late Cretaceous of France
Geological Magazine
(2013) - et al.
The giant flightless bird Gargantuavis philoinos from the Late Cretaceous of southwestern Europe: a review
Pelvic elements of the giant bird Gargantuavis from the Upper Cretaceous of Cruzy (southern France), with remarks on pneumatisation
Cretaceous Research
A femur of the Late Cretaceous giant bird Gargantuavis from Cruzy (southern France) and its systematic implications
Palaeovertebrata
A new giant ground bird from the Upper Cretaceous of southern France
Journal of the Geological Society
Gargantuavis philoinos: Giant bird or giant pterosaur?
Annales de Paléontologie
A large French Cretaceous bird
Nature
New remains of the giant bird Gargantuavis philoinos from the Late Cretaceous of Provence (south-eastern France)
Palaeovertebrata
A femur of the giant bird Gargantuavis from the Late Cretaceous of Var (south-eastern France)
Carnets Natures
Basal bird phylogeny. Problems and solutions
Insight into the growth dynamics and systematic affinities of the Late Cretaceous Gargantuavis from bone microstructure
Naturwissenschaften
Phylogenetic relationships and monophyly of loons, grebes and hesperornithiform birds, with comments on the early history of : birds
Systematic Zoology
Island in the Cretaceous- faunal composition, biogeography, evolution, and extinction of land- living vertebrates on the Late Cretaceous European archipelago
ZooKeys
Mesozoic plate tectonic reconstruction of the Carpathian region
Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology
Journal of Researches
Cited by (10)
A new enantiornithine bird from Upper Cretaceous non-marine deposits at Villespassans (Hérault, southern France)
2023, Annales de PaleontologieSpatial and Temporal Distribution of the Island-Dwelling Kogaionidae (Mammalia, Multituberculata) in the Uppermost Cretaceous of Transylvania (Western Romania)
2022, Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History