Inferring longevity from advanced rib remodelling in insular dwarf deer

Abstract

Dwarfed insular mammals are of significant interest to evolutionary biology because of their morphological and physiological adaptations triggered by variables inherent to geographical isolation. One life history trait that is expected to be modified in relation to body size reduction is extended longevity facilitated by ecological parameters such as predator and competitor release and fluctuating resource availability. However, systematic examination of longevity in extreme cases of dwarfism is difficult as such cases are largely represented by fossils of extinct species. We studied seven rib fragments of the extraordinary endemic Pleistocene dwarf deer Candiacervus (size 2) to test whether its bone matrix shows evidence for extensive bone remodelling typically seen in large and long-living mammals. We found that all ribs had well-remodelled Haversian bone, implying several generations of resorption and re-deposition processes. Osteon density was high relative to small bone cross-section size, with examples of porosity similar to that seen in elderly animals. We report the first combined micro-morphological and micro-morphometric record of Candiacervus rib histology, agreeing with previous literature discussing the evolutionary biology of dwarf ruminants. Further experimental validation of osteon density in extant deer will confirm whether dwarfed Candiacervus indeed lived longer than expected for its body mass.