User menu

Accès à distance ? S'identifier sur le proxy UCLouvain

Is genetic drift a force?

Primary tabs

download
  • Open access
  • PDF
  • 148.37 K
Pence, Charles H. [UCL]

One hotly debated philosophical question in the analysis of evolutionary theory concerns whether or not evolution and the various factors which constitute it (selection, drift, mutation, and so on) may profitably be considered as analogous to “forces” in the traditional, Newtonian sense. Several compelling arguments assert that the force picture is incoherent, due to the peculiar nature of genetic drift. I consider two of those arguments here—that drift lacks a predictable direction, and that drift is constitutive of evolutionary systems—and show that they both fail to demonstrate that a view of genetic drift as a force is untenable. I go on to diagnose the reasons for the stubborn persistence of this problem, considering two open philosophical issues and offering some preliminary arguments in support of the force metaphor.

Document type Article de périodique (Journal article) – Article de recherche
Access type Accès libre
Publication date 2017
Language Anglais
Journal information "Synthese" - Vol. 194, no.6, p. 1967-1988 (2016)
Peer reviewed yes
Publisher Springer Nature
issn 0039-7857
e-issn 1573-0964
Publication status Publié
Affiliation UCL - SSH/ISP - Institut supérieur de philosophie
Links
  1. Barros D. Benjamin, Natural Selection as a Mechanism*, 10.1086/593075
  2. Batterman Robert W., Theories between theories: Asymptotic limiting intertheoretic relations, 10.1007/bf01090047
  3. Butts Robert E., Philosophy of Science: 1934-1984, 10.1086/289159
  4. Beatty, J. H. (1992). Random drift. In E. F. Keller & E. A. Lloyd (Eds.), Keywords in evolutionary biology (pp. 273–281). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  5. Bigelow John, Ellis Brian, Pargetter Robert, Forces, 10.1086/289464
  6. Brandon Robert N., The Difference Between Selection and Drift: A Reply to Millstein, 10.1007/s10539-004-1070-9
  7. Brandon Robert N., , The Principle of Drift : Biology’s First Law, 10.5840/jphil2006103723
  8. Brandon Robert N., A Non-Newtonian Newtonian Model of Evolution: The ZFEL View, 10.1086/656901
  9. Brandon Robert N., Carson Scott, The Indeterministic Character of Evolutionary Theory: No "No Hidden Variables Proof" but No Room for Determinism Either, 10.1086/289915
  10. Carroll, S. B., Grenier, J., & Weatherbee, S. (2001). From DNA to diversity: Molecular genetics and the evolution of animal design. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
  11. Creary, L. G. (1981). Causal explanation and the reality of natural component forces. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly, 62, 148–157.
  12. Crow, J. F., & Kimura, M. (1970). An introduction to population genetics theory. Caldwell, NJ: Blackburn Press.
  13. De Jong G., The Fitness of Fitness Concepts and the Description of Natural Selection, 10.1086/418431
  14. Depew David, Conceptual Change and the Rhetoric of Evolutionary Theory: ‘Force Talk’ as a Case Study and Challenge for Science Pedagogy, The Philosophy of Biology (2013) ISBN:9789400765368 p.121-144, 10.1007/978-94-007-6537-5_7
  15. DesAutels Lane, Toward a propensity interpretation of stochastic mechanism for the life sciences, 10.1007/s11229-015-0694-4
  16. Earman J., Friedman M., The Meaning and Status of Newton's Law of Inertia and the Nature of Gravitational Forces, 10.1086/288536
  17. ELLIS BRIAN, UNIVERSAL AND DIFFERENTIAL FORCES, 10.1093/bjps/xiv.55.177
  18. Ellis Brian, The existence of forces, 10.1016/0039-3681(76)90015-7
  19. Filler Joshua, Newtonian Forces and Evolutionary Biology: A Problem and Solution for Extending the Force Interpretation, 10.1086/605799
  20. Forber Patrick, Reisman Kenneth, Can There Be Stochastic Evolutionary Causes?, 10.1086/525608
  21. Forster Malcolm R., Unification, explanation, and the composition of causes in Newtonian mechanics, 10.1016/0039-3681(88)90020-9
  22. Gildenhuys P., An Explication of the Causal Dimension of Drift, 10.1093/bjps/axp019
  23. Glennan Stuart, Productivity, relevance and natural selection, 10.1007/s10539-008-9137-7
  24. Hartl, D. L., & Clark, A. G. (1997). Principles of population genetics (3rd ed.). Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates.
  25. Heil, J. (1999). Multiple realizability. American Philosophical Quarterly, 36(3), 189–208. doi: 10.2307/20009964 .
  26. Heil John, Levels of Reality, 10.1111/1467-9329.00218
  27. HESSE MARY B., REVIEWS, 10.1093/bjps/x.37.69
  28. Hitchcock Christopher, Velasco Joel D., Evolutionary and Newtonian Forces, 10.3998/ergo.12405314.0001.002
  29. Hodge, M. J. S. (1987). Natural selection as a causal, empirical, and probabilistic theory, Volume 2: Ideas in the sciences. In L. Krüger, G. Gigerenzer, & M. S. Morgan (Eds.), The probabilistic revolution (pp. 233–270). Cambridge, MA: Bradford Books.
  30. Huilgol, R. R., & Phan-Thien, N. (1997). Fluid mechanics of viscoelasticity. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
  31. Huneman Philippe, Natural Selection: A Case for the Counterfactual Approach, 10.1007/s10670-011-9306-y
  32. Hüttemann, A. (2009). Dispositions in physics. In G. Damschen, R. Schnepf, & K. Stueber (Eds.), Debating dispositions (pp. 223–237). Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
  33. Jablonski David, Mass extinctions and macroevolution, 10.1666/0094-8373(2005)031[0192:meam]2.0.co;2
  34. Jammer, M. (1957). Concepts of force: A study in the foundations of dynamics. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  35. Kim Jaegwon, The Layered Model: Metaphysical Considerations, 10.1080/10002002018538719
  36. Lemons Don S., Gythiel Anthony, Paul Langevin’s 1908 paper “On the Theory of Brownian Motion” [“Sur la théorie du mouvement brownien,” C. R. Acad. Sci. (Paris) 146, 530–533 (1908)], 10.1119/1.18725
  37. Lewens Tim, Natural selection then and now, 10.1111/j.1469-185x.2010.00128.x
  38. Lewis, R. (1997). Life. Boston: WCB/McGraw-Hill.
  39. Lewontin, R. C. (1964). The interaction of selection and linkage: I. General considerations; heterotic models. Genetics, 49(1), 49–67.
  40. Lewontin, R. C., & Kojima, K. (1960). The evolutionary dynamics of complex polymorphisms. Evolution, 14(4), 458–472.
  41. Lynch Michael, Conery John, Burger Reinhard, Mutation Accumulation and the Extinction of Small Populations, 10.1086/285812
  42. Lyttle Terrence W., Cheaters sometimes prosper: distortion of mendelian segregation by meiotic drive, 10.1016/0168-9525(93)90120-7
  43. Machamer Peter, Darden Lindley, Craver Carl F., Thinking about Mechanisms, 10.1086/392759
  44. Mani G. S., Clarke B. C., Mutational Order: A Major Stochastic Process in Evolution, 10.1098/rspb.1990.0025
  45. MASSIN Olivier, The Metaphysics of Forces : The Metaphysics of Forces, 10.1111/j.1746-8361.2009.01213.x
  46. Matthen Mohan, Ariew André, , Two Ways of Thinking About Fitness and Natural Selection : , 10.2307/3655552
  47. Matthen Mohan, Ariew André, Selection and Causation*, 10.1086/648102
  48. Maudlin, T. (2004). Causation, counterfactuals, and the third factor. In J. D. Collins, N. Hall, & L. A. Paul (Eds.), Causation and counterfactuals (pp. 419–443). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
  49. McShea, D. W. (1996). Metazoan complexity and evolution: Is there a trend? Evolution, 50(2), 477–492.
  50. McShea Daniel W., The evolution of complexity without natural selection, a possible large-scale trend of the fourth kind, 10.1666/0094-8373(2005)031[0146:teocwn]2.0.co;2
  51. McShea Daniel W., Brandon Robert N., Biology's First Law : The Tendency for Diversity and Complexity to Increase in Evolutionary Systems, ISBN:9780226562261, 10.7208/chicago/9780226562278.001.0001
  52. Merlin Francesca, Evolutionary Chance Mutation: A Defense of the Modern Synthesis' Consensus View, 10.3998/ptb.6959004.0002.003
  53. Millstein Roberta L., Are Random Drift and Natural Selection Conceptually Distinct?, 10.1023/a:1012990800358
  54. Millstein Roberta L., Selection vs. Drift: A Response to Brandon’s Reply, 10.1007/s10539-004-6047-1
  55. Millstein Roberta L., Natural Selection as a Population-Level Causal Process, 10.1093/bjps/axl025
  56. Millstein Roberta L., Natural Selection and Causal Productivity, Mechanism and Causality in Biology and Economics (2013) ISBN:9789400724532 p.147-163, 10.1007/978-94-007-2454-9_8
  57. Pence C. H., Ramsey G., A New Foundation for the Propensity Interpretation of Fitness, 10.1093/bjps/axs037
  58. Perrin, J. B. (1909). Mouvement brownien et réalité moléculaire. Annales de Chimie et de Physique, VIII(18), 5–114.
  59. Pigliucci Massimo, Okasha’s evolution and the levels of selection: toward a broader conception of theoretical biology : Oxford University Press, Oxford, 10.1007/s10539-010-9197-3
  60. Pigliucci Massimo, Kaplan Jonathan, Making Sense of Evolution : The Conceptual Foundations of Evolutionary Biology, ISBN:9780226668376, 10.7208/chicago/9780226668352.001.0001
  61. Ramsey Grant, Driftability, 10.1007/s11229-012-0232-6
  62. Reisman Kenneth, Forber Patrick, Manipulation and the Causes of Evolution, 10.1086/508120
  63. Rosenberg Alex, Discussion Note: Indeterminism, Probability, and Randomness in Evolutionary Theory, 10.1086/392941
  64. Rupert Robert D., Ceteris ParibusLaws, Component Forces, and the Nature of Special-Science Properties1, 10.1111/j.1468-0068.2008.00685.x
  65. Shapiro, L., & Sober, E. (2007). Epiphenomenalism-The dos and the don’ts. In G. Wolters & P. Machamer (Eds.), Thinking about causes: From Greek philosophy to modern physics (pp. 235–264). Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
  66. Shpaka Max, Proulx Stephen R., The Role of Life Cycle and Migration in Selection for Variance in Offspring Number, 10.1007/s11538-006-9164-y
  67. Sober, E. (1984). The nature of selection. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
  68. Stephens Christopher, Selection, Drift, and the “Forces” of Evolution*, 10.1086/423751
  69. Stephens Christopher, Forces and Causes in Evolutionary Theory, 10.1086/656821
  70. Sterelny Kim, Last Will and Testament: Stephen Jay Gould’s The Structure of Evolutionary TheoryStephen Jay  Gould, The Structure of Evolutionary Theory. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, (2002), xxii + 1433., 10.1086/375466
  71. Strickberger, M. W. (1968). Genetics. New York: Macmillan.
  72. Fraassen Bas. C. van, The Scientific Image, ISBN:9780198244271, 10.1093/0198244274.001.0001
  73. Walsh D. M., The Pomp of Superfluous Causes: The Interpretation of Evolutionary Theory*, 10.1086/520777
  74. Walsh Denis M., Not a Sure Thing: Fitness, Probability, and Causation*, 10.1086/651320
  75. Walsh Denis , Lewins Tim , Ariew André, The Trials of Life: Natural Selection and Random Drift*, 10.1086/342454
  76. Werndl C., What Are the New Implications of Chaos for Unpredictability?, 10.1093/bjps/axn053
  77. Wilson J., Newtonian Forces, 10.1093/bjps/axm004
  78. WILSON Jessica, The Causal Argument Against Component Forces : The Causal Argument Against Component Forces, 10.1111/j.1746-8361.2009.01216.x
  79. Woodward James, Hitchcock Christopher, Explanatory Generalizations, Part I: A Counterfactual Account, 10.1111/1468-0068.00426
Bibliographic reference Pence, Charles H.. Is genetic drift a force?. In: Synthese, Vol. 194, no.6, p. 1967-1988 (2016)
Permanent URL http://hdl.handle.net/2078.1/202857